JANE WITHERS was never second fiddle

For many of us Jane Withers is the woman who, as a child, played Shirley Temple's nemesis. She ripped the head off of a doll with such glee that I was convinced this is who this person really was. I loved Shirley which meant I had to dislike Jane. If I'd been born earlier I'd have known that wasn't the real Jane Withers. I missed out on Jane's youthful career as a star of her own films. It wasn't until Josephine the Plumber came along that I began to find out who she was. Took me awhile to get used to seeing her as a grown woman when years before I'd first seen her as a child actor. Such is life when you grow up watching movies from the 1930s when you're actually born in the 1950s.
Jane Withers (born April 12, 1926) is an American actress best known for being one of the most popular child film stars of the 1930s and early 1940s, as well as for her portrayal of "Josephine the Plumber" in a series of TV commercials for Comet cleanser in the 1960s and early 1970s.

Withers began her career as a child actress, first on local radio broadcasts in Atlanta, Georgia as "Dixie's Dainty Dewdrop". By the age of three, she was singing and imitating adult celebrities. In the early 1930s Withers and her family moved to Hollywood; she worked as an extra and a bit part player in several films in 1932 and 1933.

Withers's big break came when she landed a supporting role in the 1934 Shirley Temple film Bright Eyes. Her character Joy Smythe was spoiled and obnoxious, a perfect foil to Temple's sweet personality. In a 2006 interview on TCM's Private Screenings with Robert Osborne, Withers recalled that she was hesitant to take this role because she had to be so "mean" to Shirley Temple and she thought the public would hate her for it (video clip). In a humorous scene of the two little girls playing with dolls, Withers tells Temple that she is going to the kitchen to get "the biggest knife I can find and operate on YOUR doll!" She also tells Temple: "There ain't any Santa Claus, because my psychoanalyst told me!" Withers received positive notices for her work, and was awarded a long-term contract with Fox.

Through the remainder of the 1930s she starred in several movies every year, including Ginger (1935), The Farmer Takes a Wife (1935) and Little Miss Nobody (1936), usually cast as a wholesome, meddlesome young girl in films less sugary than Temple's vehicles. Moviegoers flocked to see her films, and Withers became one of the top 10 box-office stars in 1937 and 1938. Her popularity was such that Fox gave her "name" co-stars: the Ritz Brothers (in Pack Up Your Troubles) and Gene Autry (in Shooting High). Withers also took a flyer in screenwriting: she wrote the original story filmed as Small Town Deb, under the pseudonym "Jerrie Walters." (SOURCE: Wikipedia)
It's because of Jane Withers that I began collecting vintage paper dolls. Seeing her doll collection in person was all I needed to get the collecting juices bubbling. I just wish I had some actual Jane Withers paper dolls. Several were printed by the Whitman Company in the 1930s and 40s. (See Mary Young's "Lowe and Whitman Paper Dolls" pg.s 40, 44, 46, and 49). You'll often find them for sale on eBay. They're on my want list. Especially the set illustrated by Avis Mack. I want an original, just like the lady herself.

Jane Withers post card_ft_tatteredandlost

Jane Withers card_bk_tatteredandlost

Jane Withers is one classy lady.


  1. Well, by golly, I just hate the way she picks on Shirley.

  2. I was ten years old in 1938 so Jane Withers and Shirley Temple (also Deanna Durbin) werejust about my age. I can remember liking Jane better than Shirley, although Shirley was a doll for sure. Love the tap dancing clip. The only lessons I ever had other than school were tap dancing lessons. I did a mean shuffle off to Buffalo! Carol

  3. Once I found out what a nice lady Jane Withers was I was upset that for so long she was just the mean girl in Shirley's movies. I can remember seeing her on the Mike Douglas show and thinking "What a nice lady."

    Ohhhhh...shuffle off to Buffalo. Always wanted to be able to do that. My mom took some tap lessons but all she remembered was the time step. I never did get the hang of it.

  4. If you would like to see the inside of E. A. Lawson's General Store and also a picture of my little brother standing there go to August of 2009 - I think it is the 18th. A really cool picture I am sure you will just love. Carol

  5. I wonder if kids now days ever take tap.

  6. Carol, thanks for sending me to this photo. It's great! "Excuse me, do you have Prince Albert in a can?" "Yes." "Well then would you please let him out!" Oh, that used to be a good one on the phone. For anyone who wants to see a great shot of an old general store interior go to Carol's site: http://tinyurl.com/23asu3s

    Eloh, There have to be some kids taking tap. Have to be. Probably just not as popular anymore. They all want to do hip-hop.

  7. Jane was just as talented as Shirley, IMO! Loved the dancing clip. I've always wanted to learn to tap. We never had the money when I was a kid, so I lived vicariously through films. Ahhh, those huge dance production numbers...I loved them all!

  8. I don't recall ever seeing any of Jane's movies. Shirley's movies were shown every weekend, but never any of Jane's. I don't know if they ever show up on TCM.